Straight answer
Should we pay the ransom?
Treat it as a last resort, never a reflex. Payment buys only a promise from a criminal. It does not guarantee working systems or that stolen data stays private, and in some cases it may be unlawful. The decision turns on whether you can restore cleanly without paying, what your lawyers and insurer advise, and who would receive the money.
How can the board tell whether it is under control?
Signs it is under control
- The board agreed in advance who takes the payment decision and what it would need to see.
- Legal advice, the insurer and specialist responders are already identified and can be reached quickly.
- Management can show whether clean restoration is possible, and how long it would take.
Signs it is not
- The first discussion of payment happens during an attack, with no prior view.
- Nobody can say who checks whether the attackers are subject to sanctions.
- The case for paying rests on speed alone, with no evidence that restoring would be slower.
What is the one question to ask?
If we were asked for a ransom tomorrow, who would decide, and what would they need to see first?
A strong answer
A named decision-maker or committee, a short list of inputs (restoration options, legal advice, insurer position, sanctions checks, effect on customers) and a plan for getting them quickly.
A weak answer
“We would never pay, so we have not planned for it.”
What goes into the decision?
The first question is practical: can you restore your systems and data from clean backups, and how long would that take? If restoration is possible in a time the business can bear, the case for paying is weak. If it is not, the pressure grows, but payment still buys only a promise from a criminal.
The second is legal. Paying certain people, groups or countries can be unlawful, and attackers rarely say who they are. Lawyers and specialist investigators need to assess who is likely to receive the money and how confident they can be, not just check a list. There may also be reporting duties to regulators or law enforcement, with deadlines. Take legal advice early and keep a record of it.
The third is the insurer. Many cyber policies set conditions on how an incident is handled and who is engaged. Check your policy now, not during an attack, and involve the insurer from the start.
Finally, consider customers, staff and reputation, including whether stolen data could still be published after payment.
What might the board be getting wrong?
Some boards say “we will never pay” and treat that as a plan. It is a position, and may well be the right one, but it does not tell anyone how to restore the business. Other boards leave the whole decision to management, then question it afterwards. This is a decision the board should own, or at least frame, in advance.
What should the board ask for instead?
Ask for a short paper, agreed before any incident, setting out who decides on payment, what inputs they need, and who provides each one: restoration status, legal advice, insurer position and sanctions screening. Rehearse the decision in an exercise. Review the paper when the insurance policy is renewed.