Straight answer

Is our cyber report telling us anything?

Often not much, because it reports activity instead of risk. A useful cyber report tells the board whether the company is inside its agreed risk appetite, what has changed since last time, and what management needs the board to decide. If yours is mostly counts of blocked attacks and training completion, ask for a different format.

How can the board tell whether it is under control?

Signs it is under control

  • The report starts with a short view of the main risks and whether each is getting better or worse.
  • It shows the same measures each time, against targets the board has agreed.
  • It ends with decisions or support management needs from the board.

Signs it is not

  • Most of the report is large numbers of blocked emails or attacks, with no context.
  • The colours have not changed in a year, but incidents and audit findings keep appearing.
  • The board has never been asked to decide anything from the report.

What is the one question to ask?

Ask at the next meeting

What are our three biggest cyber risks today, and are they getting better or worse?

A strong answer

Three named risks in business terms, a measure for each with a trend, the action under way, and a date when the board will see the next result.

A weak answer

“We blocked several million attacks last quarter and our maturity score has improved.”

Why do cyber reports say so little?

Security teams measure what their tools count: emails filtered, attacks blocked, patches applied, staff trained. Those numbers are real, but they describe effort, not exposure. A board cannot tell from them whether the company could keep trading after a serious attack, or whether risk is rising.

A good report translates the security work into the board’s language. It names the few risks that matter most, such as losing a critical system, losing customer data, or a key supplier being compromised. It shows a measure for each, a trend, and whether the company is inside the appetite the board has set. It flags what has changed and what the board needs to decide.

What might the board be getting wrong?

Reports often look the way they do because the board never said what it wanted. If the board has not agreed a risk appetite for cyber, management has nothing to report against. If directors react to bad news with alarm, reports will drift towards reassurance. And if the board gives cyber ten minutes at the end of a long agenda, the report will be written to be skimmed. The security chief may be doing exactly what the board’s habits asked for.

What should the board ask for instead?

Agree a short format with management and keep it stable. Ask for the top risks in business terms, a small set of measures with targets and trends, results from recent tests and exercises, open audit findings with dates, and a section for decisions. Ask too for an independent view from time to time, so the report is not only management marking its own work. Then give it proper time on the agenda.

Where to go from here