If one or two of our key technology people left next month, what would stop working, and how long would it take to recover?
In many companies, critical systems and supplier relationships are understood by very few people, often below the leadership team. Boards rarely see this risk until someone resigns, and by then the options are poor.
What a strong answer includes
- Names, by role if not by name, the few people whose departure would hurt most, and the systems, suppliers or processes each one holds.
- Says for each what is written down, what is not, and who could step in today.
- Gives a realistic recovery time for each, including the time to hire or contract a replacement and bring them up to speed.
- Looks below the leadership team and outside the company, for example a long-serving developer, a contractor or a supplier's account lead.
- Sets out actions with owners and dates, such as documentation, pairing a second person, retention arrangements or a support contract.
What a weak answer sounds like
- “Everyone is replaceable. We have a strong team.”
- “It's all documented.” Ask who last used the documentation to fix something.
- “Our partner would cover it.” Check whether the contract says so.
- “We have a succession plan for the leadership team.” That covers the top roles, not the people who keep the systems running.
If the answer is weak, ask
For the person we could least afford to lose, what has changed in the last six months to reduce our dependence on them?
Red flags
- The same one or two names come up whenever a serious problem is fixed.
- Key people never take a proper break, because things go wrong while they are away.
- Old or bespoke systems are looked after by a single person or a single small supplier.
- Cover for key roles is described as “we can always call them if needed”.
Ask for in writing
- A key-person dependency list, by role, showing the system or relationship each holds, the cover in place and the estimated recovery time.
- The state of documentation and handover for each system on that list.
- Any retention arrangements in place for people on the list, and who approved them.